|
Worked example A large box is deliberately chosen for this example to make sure we have some problem resonances to deal with
|
|
Let us start with some typical parameters derived from a speaker design program such as WinISD
|
|
Enter Panel, driver and port details Check that Panel thickness is set to 18mm ....and.... Check that Double thickness Front is ticked Use the Dropdown list to select a driver Size of 10 inch ....and.... Set No. of drivers field to 2 Set Port length field to 645 ....and.... Set Internal diameter field to 102 Set Port wall thickness field to 2 ....and.... Set Number of Ports field to 3
Enter volume Enter 130 into the Internal Volume field. The field background turns light red to indicate that it has been changed and that the box dimensions have not yet been recalculated Double click on the Box depth field to calculate initial dimensions Looking at the Tuning Summary, we see that the Working volume is about 108 litres, which is about 22 litres short of what we want Go back to the Internal volume field and add this amount - change it to 152 litres and double click on Box depth field to recalculate dimensions We now see that the Working volume is close enough to our target of 130 litres
Set minimum dimensions Click the Min button to bring up the Minimum Dimensions screen. This screen inherits the driver diameter and box panel thickness from the main screen. Click the graphic that corresponds with the driver arrangement. In this case the 2nd graphic is the one which shows 2 drivers. This tells us that to fit our two drivers, the minimum box width is 276mm and minimum height is 534mm. Click the Transfer button to copy the minimum width and height values onto the main screen. Click the OK button to return to the main screen. Double click the Box depth field to calculate its value, producing a value of 1325mm
Adjust box dimensions and examine resonances We now have all the parameters entered and have a working box, albeit badly dimensioned. Looking at the Spectral Display, we see two red resonances at the left of the display. Checking the Resonances Display, we see a Driver-to-rear-wall resonance of 67hz and a Box-front-to-back resonance of 135hz. Obviously for a subwoofer these are unacceptable.
Change the Box depth field to a value that would be more practical. The easiest size of MDF sheet to handle is 600mm * 1800, so adding 18mm for the front panel and subtracting 5mm for cleaning up the rear edge with a router gives us a box depth of 613mm. Set the Box depth field to 613 and double click the Box height field We see that the height is now 1168mm, with a Box-top-to-bottom resonance of 151hz. The Driver-to-rear-wall resonance is 155hz, which is close enough to 151hz for the two to occur simultaneously, which would produce a large peak in response. There is also a Driver-to-bottom-wall res of 90hz
Reduce the Box height field to 900mm and double click the Box width field The Box-top-to-bottom resonance is now 199hz which is OK for a sub. The Driver-to-bottom resonance is now 126hz, which is slill too low, so move the driver down to the centre of the box. Set the Box top to driver centre field to 450. This changes the resonance to 199hz, but this is the same as the Box-top-to-bottom resonance and will reinforce it. To avoid this, move the driver back up by 100mm. Set the Box top to driver centre field to 350, which changes the resonance to 161hz The Driver-to-rear-wall resonance of 151hz is fairly close to 161hz, so lets trade off box depth against box width to move the Driver-to-rear-wall resonance to half way between 161 and 199 - lets aim for 180hz. Set the Box width field to 400 and double click the Box depth field, causing it to recalculate. Luckily we found our desired resonance of 180hz on the first go, with box depth being 537mm.
|
|
Check for higher frequency problems When a subwoofer is pushed to its limits, harmonics are produced which may excite higher frequency resonances. Looking at the Spectral Display, we see a grouping of resonances around 470hz produced by the box width dimension. This can be helped by moving the driver sideways. Change the Driver offset to vertical centreline field to 20mm. We see that the group of resonances has now spread into frequencies of 425hz, 472hz and 530hz.
There is another pair of resonances around 260hz, where the Driver-to-top-wall res lines up with the Port resonance. Moving the driver up or down a bit will fix this. The Driver-to-bottom-wall res is 160hz and we don't want it to go any lower, so move the driver down a bit. Set the Box top to driver centre field to 380mm, which moves the Driver-to-top-wall res to 237hz
This has moved the Driver-to-bottom-wall res to 171hz.- close to the Driver-to-rear-wall resonance of 180hz Decreasing the depth slightly will fix this. Increase the Box width field to 410mm and double click the Box depth field to yield a new value of 524mm Finally we have all our resonances well spaced with the lowest one being 171hz
Summing up Resonances below 200hz (shown in red) are Driver-to-rear-wall , Box-top-to-bottom and Driver-to-bottom-wall. This would suggest damping foam should be fitted to the rear wall, the top wall and the bottom wall. Side walls do not need treatment. The box is not deep enough to contain straight ports, so 90 degree bends will be required. The box sides need to be cut from a 600mm wide sheet of MDF The box front and back panels can be cut from a 450mm wide sheet of MDF The box height of 900mm means that when saw width (5mm) and allowance for edge cleanup with router (5mm all round) are taken into account, you would not get two panels from a sheet of MDF 1800mm long. If you were actually building this speaker, you would keep massaging the dimensions to try and overcome this. Select File / Save from the menu to save a copy of your project. You may also wish to select Print from the menu to print a copy of your project. Select the Cutting List option from the menu to access the cutting list screen Click the display option you require and then click the Print button to get your cutting list. For more control over what is printed, use the File / Generate Report option from the menu. This will produce a textfile which you can then print from notepad, or import into a word processor.
If you find Boxnotes useful, please consider mentioning it to others online, and perhaps provide a link to this site |
Last update to this page 10/04/06